句子：There is a bird in the sky."in the sky"到底是狀語還是定語？拿不準(zhǔn)的朋友請(qǐng)勿答！

熱心網(wǎng)友

The other day I explained this to you。 But apparently you failed to grasp the gist of my analysis。 This time let me change the method and approach the question from another angle。Please look at the sentence in (1) and try to determine what grammatical function the prepositional phrase plays。(1) John is in the room。The spatial prepositional phrase does not function as an adverbial, nor does it function as a modifer。 The phrase serves as complement。 And it is this relation that holds between "a bird" and "in the sky" in the existential sentence。As for the existential sentence, compare the Chinese sentences in (2)(2) a。 you yizhi niao zaitianshang。 itianshangyouyizhiniao。。

熱心網(wǎng)友

狀語

熱心網(wǎng)友

應(yīng)該是個(gè)地點(diǎn)狀語.如果你要說The bird in the sky is ...這里的in the sky 才是定語。

熱心網(wǎng)友

狀語，具體的說是地點(diǎn)狀語。

熱心網(wǎng)友

是地點(diǎn)狀語修飾鳥不過現(xiàn)在英語不能再這樣子讀了英語中這些東西不要死記能分析句子成分就行了；

熱心網(wǎng)友

表示地點(diǎn)的地點(diǎn)狀語

熱心網(wǎng)友

是后置定語，修飾bird類似的有：There are some　ｂｏｏｋｓ　（ｏｎ　ｔｈｅ　ｄｅｓｋ）。

熱心網(wǎng)友

定語是用來修是名詞的，但您來看這個(gè)，如果有beautiful bird ，那么beautiful是修是bird的，是定語，而in the sky 按理來說是狀語，地點(diǎn)狀語。

熱心網(wǎng)友

是狀語

熱心網(wǎng)友

定語 對(duì)BIRD做出補(bǔ)充 補(bǔ)充它的狀態(tài)